Leading Gold IRA & Precious Metals Experts - Global Gold Investments

401(k) vs 403(b) vs 457 vs SEP vs SIMPLE: Can You Move Gold?


Short answer: A 401(k), a 403(b), a SEP IRA, a SIMPLE IRA, a traditional IRA and — once you have left the job — a governmental 457(b) can all move into a self-directed precious metals IRA. Three behave differently: a 457(b) locks your money in the plan, it is not self-directed, and a Roth IRA is lawful for metal but almost impossible to fund. And one fact applies to all of them: you cannot roll physical metal out of an employer plan. A 401(k), 403(b) or 457(b) pays you cash, and you buy the metal inside the IRA afterwards.

The account type decides when money can leave, not where it goes. Most confusion comes from treating “gold IRA” as a category of its own rather than an IRA that holds metal.

Every in-service and 457(b) statement below is a general rule. Your plan document governs, and plan documents differ. Confirm specifics with your administrator.

The comparison table

Account typeWho offers itVestingCan you leave and roll overIn-service rollover from this accountSelf-directed allowed?Convert to a Roth IRA?2026 limitRMD treatment
401(k)Private employersPer plan — often a 3-year cliffYes, on separation from serviceRarely — after-tax portion only, after 2 yrs’ serviceNo — plan menu. The rolled-over IRA can beYes, as a conversion. Pre-tax taxed on conversion$24,500 + catch-up73/75, deferred while still employed
403(b)Public schools, tax-exempt organisations, some ministersPer planYes, on separation from serviceRarely — after-tax portion onlyNo — plan menu. The rolled-over IRA can beYes, as a conversion$24,500 + catch-upSame as 401(k)
Governmental 457(b)State/local government and tax-exempt employersFully vested, if fundedYes, on separation from serviceNo, except unforeseeable emergencyNo. Plan sets the menu; bullion is not on itYes, as a conversion$24,500 — stacks with a 403(b)Generally none while deferring. No 10% penalty
Non-governmental 457(b) (“top hat”)Private employers, HCEs onlyPer planYes, on separation from serviceNoNo — employer-directedYes, if the plan accepts$24,500Generally none while deferring. No 10% penalty
SEP IRAEmployers of any size, including the self-employedNone — immediately yoursYes, any time. No employment conditionN/A — no employment relationshipYes, with a self-directed custodianYes, as a conversion$72,000 (415(c))RMD 73/75
SIMPLE IRAEmployers with 100 or fewer employees2 years employer contributionsYes, after the 2-year ruleN/A — no employment relationshipYes, with a self-directed custodianYes, as a conversion$17,000 + catch-upRMD 73/75. 25% penalty in year 1–2
Traditional IRAYou, individuallyN/A — yoursYes, any timeN/A — no employment relationshipYesYes — the classic conversion$7,500, or $8,600 at 50+RMD at 73/75
Roth IRAYou, individuallyN/A — yoursYes, any timeN/A — no employment relationshipLawfully yes, rarely in practiceAlready Roth$7,500, or $8,600 at 50+None, ever

Both 457(b) rows are treated the same way on purpose: RMD obligations generally do not begin while you are still deferring, and your plan’s rules decide whether a scheduled payment exists.

Two columns do most of the work: “can you leave and roll over” describes the source account, “self-directed allowed?” the destination. A 401(k) is not self-directed and never will be; the IRA you roll it into can be. The Roth column exists because moving pre-tax money into a Roth is a conversion, taxed at conversion.

How the money moves

Two paths exist under IRC §402(c). Direct (trustee to trustee): the plan sends the money straight to the new IRA custodian, so it never reaches your hands — no withholding, no deadline.

Indirect (60-day). The money is paid to you, and you have 60 days to redeposit it. Miss the window and it is taxable and penalised. You also face 20% withholding and one indirect rollover per 12 months.

Ask for the direct rollover every time, in writing. Full mechanics on our gold IRA transfer page; the in-service question for a former 401(k) is covered on our 401(k) rollover page.

SEP and SIMPLE: employer IRAs, not personal accounts

Both are IRAs, but neither is opened the way you open an individual one.

SEP IRA

An employer — including a self-employed individual with no employees — contributes to a SEP IRA for you. There are no employee salary deferrals, except in a SAR-SEP.

  • Vesting: none. Contributions are immediately and unconditionally yours — money deposited on your last day of work is yours that day.
  • No employment condition. You have not “left” anything, so there is nothing to wait for.
  • Self-direction is permitted. §408(m) applies in full.
  • The employer can hold metal itself, so check before moving anything.

Employer contributions run to a percentage of compensation, capped by the §415(c) limit — $72,000 for 2026, against compensation up to $360,000.

SIMPLE IRA

A small-employer plan with employee deferrals plus a mandatory employer contribution — a 3% match or 2% nonelective.

The 2-year rule. For the first two years of participation, a SIMPLE distribution carries a 25% additional tax instead of 10%, and rollovers are restricted to SIMPLE IRAs and SIMPLE 401(k) plans — you cannot reach a traditional IRA or a self-directed IRA yet. The clock starts at your first contribution, not the plan’s start. IRS Notice 2024-2 created one exception: a SIMPLE IRA may be rolled into a 401(k) or 403(b) early.

Vesting: two years on employer contributions, unlike a SEP. Salary deferrals are yours immediately. The 2026 employee deferral limit is $17,000, plus a $4,000 catch-up at 50 or over, or $5,250 for ages 60 to 63. Certain small-employer plans carry a higher $18,100 limit.

457(b): the account that locks

A 457(b) is a deferred compensation plan, which makes it neither an IRA nor a qualified plan. That single fact explains most of the confusion.

Two sub-types, one practical answer

Governmental 457(b). Offered by state and local government employers and tax-exempt organisations. The deferral limit is separate from the 401(k)/403(b) limit — $24,500 into each in 2026. Under §457(g) the plan must set assets aside for you. If yours did not, you hold a promise to pay, not money.

Non-governmental 457(b), or “top hat.” Private employers, restricted to a select group of highly compensated or management employees. Unfunded, it is the company’s promise on its balance sheet. Funded, the employer directs the investment and contributions are taxed immediately.

Why you cannot roll it out mid-employment

Section 457(d)(1)(A) says amounts are not made available until the earliest of the applicable RMD age, separation from service, or an unforeseeable emergency. There is no ordinary in-service distribution at all.

That is the 457(b)’s real structural difference from a 401(k), and it cuts against you. A 401(k) plan may let you take money in service; a governmental 457(b) will not, at any age, short of an unforeseeable emergency.

Separation from service is the unlock — not necessarily retirement, just off the payroll. The distribution then becomes an eligible rollover distribution under §402(c), and a direct transfer into a self-directed IRA is permitted.

And it is not self-directed

A 457(b) is an employer plan, so you choose among the options it offers. Physical bullion is not on the menu.

So the sequence is: leave the job, roll the 457(b) directly into a self-directed IRA, then buy metal inside that IRA.

The one thing to ask your administrator

A 457(b) plan usually meets the distribution rules through a schedule of payments rather than through a separate annual calculation. If your plan has no scheduled payment — no date on which you are set to begin drawing — there may be nothing to draw from. Ask your administrator directly: does my plan have a scheduled payment, and when does it start? Get the answer in writing.

The 10% early-distribution penalty also does not apply to section 457 distributions. That protects the 457(b) distribution itself; once the money lands in a traditional IRA, ordinary IRA penalty rules apply.

What can actually go in once the money is there

The source account has stopped mattering. What matters now is IRC §408(m), where most published material on gold IRAs goes wrong.

Coins. Section 408(m)(3)(A) reaches four separate lists: gold coins under 31 U.S.C. §5112(a)(7)–(10), which is the American Gold Eagle and the fractional gold eagles; silver coins under §5112(e); platinum coins under §5112(k); and coins issued under the laws of any State. They qualify because Congress named them, not because of a purity test. The American Gold Eagle is 91.67% fineness and qualifies because it appears in §5112(a)(7).

One coin is commonly assumed eligible and was never added to that list. The American Buffalo appears at §5112(a)(11), and §408(m)(3)(A) does not reach it. Treat IRA-eligibility claims for it with care.

Bullion. Section 408(m)(3)(B) delegates purity to contract-market standards: the minimum fineness a commodity market requires for delivery against a regulated futures contract. For gold that is the COMEX specification, .995; for silver, .999. Saying “the IRS requires 99.5% gold” as a standalone rule is inaccurate — the exchange sets the standard, and the statute points at the exchange.

Storage. Metals must be in the physical possession of the trustee — a bank, or a non-bank trustee who has demonstrated to the IRS’s satisfaction that they can administer the account consistently. No federal agency designates, approves or licenses depositories for this purpose, so if a page tells you your metal is in an “approved” vault, ask who approved it.

Home storage is the expensive mistake. In McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. No. 10 (2021), the Tax Court held that a taxpayer who took personal possession of American Eagle coins bought with IRA funds through an IRA-owned LLC received a taxable distribution. She argued §408(m) carved out an exception to §408’s custodial requirements. The Court rejected that, resting the analysis on constructive receipt and §408’s fiduciary requirements.

What qualifies: IRA-eligible metals guide.

And the Roth question

Section 408(m) does not distinguish Roth from traditional IRAs, so a Roth IRA can hold eligible metal in law. Three things work against it.

Funding a Roth means a contribution or conversion, not a rollover, and converting a traditional IRA that holds metal usually means taking an in-kind distribution first, which most custodians will not arrange for bullion. If any of your traditional IRAs also holds after-tax contributions, the pro-rata rule taxes you across the whole account. And any contribution starts a five-year clock.

What it costs

Accounts here are custodied by Equity Trust Company on its precious metals tier: a $125 annual maintenance fee plus storage at $110 commingled or $160 segregated, and a $50 setup fee in year one. Those are flat fees that do not grow with your balance. Full schedule: Gold IRA fees page.

What that page deliberately does not publish is our own dealer markup, because we have not published a figure we can stand behind. We will not quote one here either — that is the standard we would ask of anyone else.

Penalty age is not RMD age

59½ is when the 10% early-distribution penalty stops applying to most IRA and qualified-plan withdrawals. A penalty age.

73 or 75 is the required minimum distribution age, under §107 of SECURE 2.0 and T.D. 10001, 89 FR 58886: 73 for those born 1951 through 1959, 75 for those born in 1960 or later. A distribution age.

That leaves roughly fourteen to sixteen years in between, when you can withdraw without the penalty and are not yet required to take anything.

Two corrections, because the old figures are still in circulation: the former ages of 70½ and 72 are no longer current, and a Roth IRA has no RMD at any age. See our gold IRA tax benefits page.

Questions to ask

  1. Does my plan permit a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer? This is the single question that decides whether the rollover is clean. Ask for it in writing.
  2. Is my 457(b) funded? If assets were never set aside, the balance is a promise.
  3. Does my 457(b) have a scheduled payment, and when does it start?
  4. Have I passed two years on my SIMPLE IRA, and when was my first contribution? First contribution, not plan start date.
  5. Will you take a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer in writing, and what is your markup over spot on the specific product?

The broader checklist — vesting, plan documents, fees — is on our rollover checklist.

FAQ

Is a 401(k) to gold IRA rollover taxable? Not if it is a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer. The plan sends cash straight to the new IRA custodian, no distribution is reported, nothing is owed. Take the money yourself instead and you have an indirect rollover: 60 days, 20% withholding, one per 12 months.

Can I roll over gold or coins in kind? Not out of a 401(k), 403(b) or 457(b). Those plans pay cash, and the metal is bought inside the IRA afterwards. An in-kind distribution only means something once metal is already in the IRA — and taking it into your own hands is what McNulty says triggers a taxable distribution.

Can I roll my 401(k) into a Roth IRA and then buy gold? Yes, but that is a conversion, not a rollover, and the pre-tax portion is taxed as ordinary income in the year you convert. It is not a way to avoid tax. For most people buying metal, a traditional IRA is the more natural home.

Can I roll over a 403(b) into a self-directed gold IRA? Yes. Once you are separated from service, a 403(b) is an eligible rollover distribution and a direct transfer into a self-directed IRA is permitted. Some plans allow in-service rollovers of the after-tax portion only, under narrow conditions in the plan document.

Can I roll over a 457(b) into a gold IRA while I am still working? Generally, no. There is no ordinary in-service distribution, so the money usually cannot leave until you separate from service. After that, a direct rollover is permitted. The 457(b) is not self-directed either.

Can I hold physical gold in a Roth IRA? Not legally prohibited — §408(m) does not distinguish Roth from traditional. But funding a Roth means contributions or conversions, a conversion usually requires taking metal in kind first, and any contribution starts a five-year clock. Most Roth providers cannot hold vaulted metal at all.

What’s the difference between a SEP IRA and a SIMPLE IRA? Who funds it, and when you can leave. A SEP is employer-funded only, has no vesting at all, and can be rolled over any time in the year. A SIMPLE takes employee deferrals too, but needs two years of service before employer money vests and blocks rollovers for two years.

Is a SEP IRA or a SIMPLE IRA self-directed? Both can be. They are IRAs under §408(k) and §408(p), so §408(m) applies in full.

Do I have to wait until 59½ to roll over my 401(k)? No. Rollovers have no age requirement and are not early distributions. The 59½ age governs the penalty on ordinary withdrawals, which is separate.

What is the current RMD age? 73 if you were born between 1951 and 1959, and 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. Roth IRAs have no RMD at all.

Can I have a 403(b) and a 457(b) at the same time? Yes, if your employer offers both, and the limits stack. Each has a $24,500 deferral limit for 2026.

Does the source account change how gold is taxed later? Not on the metals rules. §408(m) governs them identically across traditional, SEP, SIMPLE and Roth IRAs. What differs is whether the account is pre-tax or after-tax.

Next step

Find three numbers first: your vested balance, whether the plan permits a direct rollover, and your termination or distribution fees. We will work through those with you, and tell you if your account type is a poor fit rather than take the business anyway.

If you have those answers, open an account or send us a message.

General information only. Not tax or legal advice, and no advisory relationship is created. RMD ages and limits cited are as published by the IRS for 2026 and change annually. Confirm your position with a qualified tax professional before moving money.


Sources

Share Post :

Get your FREE Investment Guide

PopUp is Working!